Why Academics Struggle with Popular Culture: A Critical Examination
Written on
Chapter 1: The Clash Between Academia and Pop Culture
When scholars find themselves at odds with popular culture, they often fall into the trap of believing that expertise in one area confers authority in all others. This phenomenon can lead to a dismissive attitude towards media that many enjoy.
Recently, I suggested a television series to a friend that I couldn't stop watching, convinced he would find it equally engaging. To my surprise, he countered with a recommendation of his own. We started watching both shows simultaneously, and I texted him that mine was superior. He replied with the same sentiment about his choice. We both found humor in our differing opinions, but it raises the question: who is right?
I might argue that my knowledge of cinema gives me the edge in appreciating nuanced references and meta-narratives. On the flip side, I could critique my friend’s understanding of the dialogue, which may be hampered by his limited proficiency in English. Yet, our disagreement might simply stem from differing tastes. Can we accept that possibility?
As we consume more media, we often become adept at articulating our views on its quality. Intellectuals, in particular, are skilled at expressing their critiques of popular culture. I have found myself guilty of this, watching more straightforward shows with friends and questioning their ability to enjoy them. I would often voice my critiques, which rarely received positive responses. It’s understandable; when someone challenges our enjoyment, we can take it personally.
Section 1.1: Aesthetic Hierarchy in Music
Pop music and the concept of aesthetic hierarchy have been in conflict since the genre's inception. The rise of icons like The Beatles, Elvis Presley, and Jimi Hendrix was often met with criticism, associating them with hedonism and teenage rebellion. Many feared that this music would lead listeners to moral decay.
Looking back, it's clear that this perception was misguided. These artists represented a significant shift from the refined compositions played in the Habsburg Palace of Schonbrunn, where Mozart once entertained royalty. Music underwent a democratization process throughout the 20th century, making it accessible to all.
If we were to compare the mainstream appeal of The Beatles with the works of Mozart or Beethoven, can we unequivocally claim one as superior? Certainly, Mozart and Beethoven showcase exceptional skill, but public interest often hinges on emotional connection and relatability. Pop songs resonate more easily with listeners, as their themes often reflect shared human experiences, such as heartbreak.
The Era of The Critic: Why are Video Essays so Popular (and Hated)? - YouTube
This video delves into the rise of video essays, exploring their impact on how we engage with culture and the criticism they receive.
Section 1.2: The Complexity of Taste
Some modern rock bands, such as Polyphia, Chon, and Animals as Leaders, push the boundaries of musical complexity, yet they remain relatively obscure. Their intricate compositions may resonate more with musicians than with the general public. In contrast, the simplicity of pop music allows for broader emotional appeal.
Critics like Susan Jacoby argue for the superiority of classical composers like Beethoven over popular artists, citing emotional depth and technical complexity. However, such evaluations are inherently subjective and reflect personal preferences rather than objective standards.
I have experienced this firsthand while introducing my favorite drummers and guitarists to friends who lack a musical background. Their inability to appreciate the nuances of these performances highlights how taste can vary widely based on one’s exposure and expertise.
Chapter 2: Embracing Diverse Aesthetic Values
Academia is TOXIC! Here's why... - YouTube
This video critiques the toxic culture within academia, discussing the disconnect between academic elitism and broader societal values.
The notion of aesthetic hierarchy often overlooks the evolving nature of beauty and taste. While I cherish classical art and literature, I also believe in the value of contemporary works, including popular fiction. Our appreciation for various forms of expression can coexist, without being dictated by elite standards.
Ultimately, the discussions surrounding populism and societal change echo historical debates. Embracing diverse perspectives fosters a richer understanding of culture. The world is more vibrant when we allow for multiple interpretations and appreciate the art that resonates with us, irrespective of its classification.
In my forthcoming book, "Beyond Reason," I further explore these themes, examining the complexities of certainty and skepticism, the role of biases in our thinking, and the shifting landscape of philosophy in modern discourse.
I invite you to connect with me on social media to stay updated on the book's release and to engage in thoughtful discussions about these pressing topics. Thank you for your support!